Trading on hope can feel productive for directors, but as Chris Worden explains, it often leads to reckless decisions and personal financial risk. This real-life case study highlights the dangers of ignoring insolvency warning signs, taking on personally guaranteed debt, and waiting too long to seek help.
- Trading on hope is risky and often reckless for directors.
- Personally guaranteed (PG) debt can destroy your personal finances.
- Ignoring HMRC arrears leads to winding up petitions and liquidation.
- Early advice gives you more options and control.
- Chris Worden shares a real case study with actionable lessons.
Case Study: When Hope Turns to Insolvency
Chris Worden recounts the story of a construction company director who, despite years of honest trading, fell into financial trouble. The director used tax money as working capital, fell behind on VAT and corporation tax, and took on more debt—including personally guaranteed loans—hoping for a turnaround that never came.
Key Mistakes Made
- Using tax funds to pay wages and contractors instead of ring-fencing them.
- Defaulting on multiple HMRC time to pay arrangements.
- Taking on new personally guaranteed debt while already insolvent.
- Relying on PG insurance without understanding exclusions.
- Delaying action until HMRC issued a winding up petition.
What Happened Next?
HMRC eventually issued a winding up petition. The director had to remortgage his home to settle an overdrawn director’s loan account and personally guaranteed debts. Chris Worden and his team negotiated a settlement, but the director still faced significant personal loss—most of which could have been avoided with earlier intervention.
Key Lessons for Directors
- Wishful thinking is not a strategy—face the numbers early.
- Personally guaranteed debt becomes your personal problem in insolvency.
- HMRC does not forget—delays only make things worse.
- Early professional advice gives you more control and options.
What Should You Do Instead?
- Get up-to-date with your creditors and HMRC returns.
- Don’t sign new PGs under pressure.
- Understand your director’s loan account position.
- Seek advice before you lose control—don’t wait for a crisis.
Key Takeaways
- Trading on hope can lead to personal financial ruin.
- Personally guaranteed debt is a major risk in insolvency.
- HMRC action is procedural and relentless.
- Early, honest advice from experts like Chris Worden is vital.
FAQs
- What is a personally guaranteed (PG) loan?
- A PG loan is a business loan where the director is personally liable if the company cannot repay it.
- What happens if I default on a HMRC time to pay arrangement?
- HMRC may escalate action, including issuing a winding up petition against your company.
- Can PG insurance protect me if my company is already insolvent?
- Usually not—PG insurance often excludes cover if the company was insolvent when the loan was taken.
- What should I do if I have an overdrawn director’s loan account?
- Seek professional advice immediately, as this is an asset the insolvency practitioner will pursue.
- How can I avoid personal financial loss as a director?
- Act early, avoid new PG debt if insolvent, and get expert advice before problems escalate.
Need confidential advice?
If you’re facing similar issues, contact us for a confidential discussion about your options.
